The crux of my preference for Smashed Together Words over the Free Link approach to Automatic Linking in a Wiki is that I believe it increases the "bushiness" of the space.
In 1997 Leo Egghe (L Egghe) wrote an article on the "Fractal And Informetric Aspects Of Hypertext Systems".
In the paper he defines the Fractal dimension of a HyperText based on the number of (internal) links it includes:
n denote the total number of pages, andm the average number of "HLs" (hypertext links) per page
Page A has 3 separate links to Page B in it (which happens in a wiki when you use the same Wiki Name multiple times in a page), then it should only count as 1 for that page)D = ln(n) / [ln(n) + ln((1+m) / m)]
fractal_dimension = log(num_pages)/(log(num_pages) + log((1 + avg_frontlinks) / avg_frontlinks))I should really work on writing some code to calculate this for various spaces... (I'm kinda surprised this hasn't been done for Wikipedia already)
Aug08'2014: realized my WikiGraph code got me 90% of the way... ended up with:
number of pages: 16506
total number of frontlinks: 85189
avg num frontlinks/page: 5.1610929359
fractal dimension: 0.982089872391
Let's compare to a fake WebLog (I've made a spreadsheet to calculate these):
number of pages: 1000
total number of frontlinks: 500
avg num frontlinks/page: 0.5 (because most blogs don't do much non-navigation in-linking)
fractal dimension: 0.862782681486289
Let's check 2 variations on that fake WebLog:
avg_frontlinks = 1.0 -> fractal dimension: 0.9088072522638707avg_frontlinks = 0.1 -> fractal dimension: 0.7423183624341485And let's compare to a smaller version of my WikiLog (note that if I had fewer pages, then I'd have fewer links/page because many WikiWords wouldn't hit matches - but we'll ignore that for now):
n=1000, avg=5.16 -> fractal dimension: 0.975002217Sept18'2014: was going to write an HTML-scraper to handle my Private Wiki, but decided to just grab the raw-text, since that's much easier.
n=2687, avg = 3.74 -> fractal dimension: 0.970874964094Hmm, what's an upper-bound? How much is too bushy? Fake scenario:
n=1000, avg=100 -> fractal dimension: 0.99856Oct29'2014: how about that TINAC-test of 3 links/page?
n=1000, avg=3 -> fractal dimension: 0.960Next
Sept'2015: realize my discomfort with this metric is that it's just about the average number of links, and not the distribution of that curve. Specifically, isn't a "rich" HyperText going to have a Power Law?
Edited: | Tweet this! | Search Twitter for discussion
Mentions: Associative | Automatic Linking | BackLinks | CommunityWiki | Fractal | Free Link | GitHub | HTML | HyperText | Intertwingularity | LEgghe | LeoEgghe | Mark Bernstein | Meatball Wiki | Power Law | Private Wiki | Python | Smashed Together Words | TINAC | WebLog | Wiki | WikiGraph | WikiLog | WikiName | Wikipedia
Backlinks: Accidental Linking | Associative | Automatic Linking | Free Link | My Pages With Most In-links |